The best Simon and Garfunkel LP depends on whether you want a broad introduction or a particular studio album. Greatest Hits is the collection-oriented choice, while Bridge Over Troubled Water, Sounds of Silence, Bookends, and Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme suit listeners seeking individual albums. The listings identify these selections as vinyl; check each product page for pressing and edition details before ordering.
| LP | Best For | Listing Details |
|---|---|---|
| Greatest Hits | A broad introduction | Vinyl; rock; 2018 release date listed |
| Bridge Over Troubled Water | A specific studio album | Vinyl; 2018 release date listed |
| Sounds of Silence | A specific studio album | Vinyl; 2018 release date listed |
| Bookends | A specific studio album | Vinyl; 2018 release date listed |
| Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme | A specific studio album | Track names are provided in the listing |
Greatest Hits
This vinyl compilation is the best fit for a listener who wants a collection rather than a single studio album. The supplied listing identifies the genre as rock and gives a release date of May 4, 2018. Those details make it straightforward to distinguish this entry from the band’s separately listed albums.
Best for: New listeners, gift shoppers, or anyone who prefers a greatest-hits format. It was selected because it offers a different listening approach from the four album-specific options in this guide.
Check before buying: The provided details do not name the tracks or explain the pressing. Review the product page if you need to confirm the song selection or a particular edition.
Bridge Over Troubled Water
This listing is for the vinyl version of Bridge Over Troubled Water, with an October 18, 2018 release date shown in the supplied information. Choose this LP if you are looking for that named album rather than a general compilation or another title in the catalog.
Best for: Collectors filling a specific gap or listeners who already know they want this album. It was selected as one of the distinct Simon and Garfunkel album options provided.
Check before buying: The available feature text does not specify track details, pressing characteristics, or packaging. Confirm those particulars on the product page if they matter to your purchase.
Sounds Of Silence
Sounds of Silence is listed in vinyl format, with an October 19, 2018 release date. This is the better choice when your search is for that specific Simon and Garfunkel album, rather than a compilation or a different album title.
Best for: Buyers building a focused album collection or replacing a copy of this title. The listing’s format and named album make it easy to compare with the other vinyl options here.
Check before buying: The supplied feature list repeats the format but does not describe the pressing or include a track listing. Verify the edition and other details on the product page.
Bookends
This Bookends listing identifies the format as vinyl and gives an October 19, 2018 release date. It is a direct album choice for shoppers who want this title in their collection, not a substitute for a greatest-hits record.
Best for: Album-focused listeners and collectors seeking Bookends specifically. It was selected to represent another distinct studio-album option in the supplied product list.
Check before buying: The provided details do not explain which pressing is offered or list its tracks. If you need a particular edition, use the product page to confirm before ordering.
Parsley, Sage, Rosemary And Thyme
This listing names the album and includes several tracks: “Scarborough Fair/Canticle,” “Patterns,” and “Cloudy.” The supplied features do not explicitly state a format, so buyers should confirm that the product page identifies the version as vinyl before purchasing an LP.
Best for: Shoppers seeking this particular album and listeners who want to check a listing against named tracks. It was chosen as a distinct title rather than another version of the same greatest-hits collection.
Check before buying: The available information provides only a partial track list and does not state pressing details. Confirm the format and full listing information on the product page.
Buying Guide: How To Choose A Simon And Garfunkel LP
Do you want a compilation or a specific album?
Choose Greatest Hits if you prefer a collection rather than one named album. Choose Bridge Over Troubled Water, Sounds of Silence, Bookends, or Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme when you are searching for that specific title. These options serve different purposes, so the album name is a useful first comparison point.
Which listing details should you verify?
Check that the product page identifies the item as vinyl and matches the album you intend to buy. The supplied descriptions do not consistently include pressing information, full track lists, or packaging details. If a particular edition or song selection matters, confirm it in the listing rather than assuming it from the album title.
Are the release dates the original album dates?
The dates supplied for several products are listing release dates, not a confirmed statement about an original album release or a specific pressing history. Treat them as product details only. The available information does not establish whether different listings use the same edition.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Simon and Garfunkel LP is best for a first-time buyer?
Greatest Hits is the collection-oriented option in this selection. Check the product page for its track list before deciding whether it fits your needs.
Which options are identified as vinyl?
The supplied details explicitly identify Greatest Hits, Bridge Over Troubled Water, Sounds of Silence, and Bookends as vinyl. Confirm the format for Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme on its product page.
Does the turquoise Greatest Hits listing add another album?
No. It is another listing for Greatest Hits, not a distinct album title. This guide prioritizes five different titles for a broader comparison.
Do these listings specify exact pressings?
The supplied product features do not consistently identify pressing details. Check the product page if edition, track selection, or packaging is important.
What should I check before ordering an LP?
Confirm the format, album title, track information, and edition details shown on the product page. Do not rely on an album name alone if you need a specific pressing.